Welcome Guest Login or Signup
FLASHCHAT | INSTANT MESSENGER | BOOKMARK
| LANGUAGE:

Social Anxiety Friends will be closing on Nov 29th
 

ennaitsirhc
PROFILE   GALLERY   BLOGS   GUESTBOOK   FRIENDS   FAVORITES   VIDEOS  
 


RSS
Is race dying?
Posted On: 12/15/2007 12:27:25

I came across a thought provoking article on one of my favorite sites to go to for news and opinion pieces, salon.com. The article entitled, Is race dying?, addresses the changes that have taken place in the United States with respect to racial issues. It focuses mainly on the reported apparent changes in beliefs among many black Americans about the 'black' racial category.

Since taking cultural anthropology in college, I've come to firmly believe that mainstream notions of the concept of race are illogical, divisive, oppressive, and have no real scientific basis. I can't really speak for non-Americans, but I was born and raised in the U.S. so what I do know is that the terms black, white, Asian (formerly Oriental, but don't get me started on that), and Hispanic (or more often used, Spanish/Latino) are commonly used by people to describe themselves as well as other people. I often refer to myself as Asian mostly because from my experience, that is how most people perceive me. But when asked specifically about my ethnicity I always acknowledge that I'm 'half' Filipino and 'half' Irish.

I can identify with many people of 100% Asian descent because of negative attitudes towards me or offensive stereotypes I have dealt with because of my appearance. But categorizing myself as Asian really means nothing else to me, and I'm not sure if other people realize that. And, I am not trying to distance myself from other people, I'm just trying to point out that these words that are used (usually without thinking about what they actually mean) are really shortcuts. In the introduction to Kip Fulbeck's book Part Asian 100% Hapa, Fulbeck writes "Our country is lazy. And I'm not talking about obesity levels...We're uncomfortable with people who don't fit neatly into boxes because when they don't do so it requires effort on our part...Compartmentalization is easy, even inviting".

The article also touches on the influence that mixed-race people are having on concepts of racial identity because many refuse to place themselves in traditional racial categories. When filling out any sort of application that asks me to check a box to indicate my race, I usually skip it altogether, and sometimes will choose 'other'. I feel that it is quite often where I feel like I have to explain myself or get irritated with others because of either their ignorant comments or rigid thinking. I simply do not want to get into a discussion about this topic every time something regarding it comes up. It's annoying. It's tiring. And people don't always get it or don't even care to explore it. So I usually let it go. But now I'm tired of writing about it, but if you're interested in reading the article, here's a link: http://www.salon.com/opinion/kamiya/2007/11/27/race/index.html



Bookmark:



Viewing 1 - 9 out of 9 Comments

From: spring37
05/08/2008 09:52:10

Good blog.  I don't think that race information should be gathered or highlighted.  I think that society puts way too much importance on race now.  I don't foresee any point in the future that race is not important.  Why should it matter if someone is 1/2 minority or not?  I feel that the "leaders" of racial issues are using the issue to their own advantage.  Some of the worst examples are city contracts that will only go to "minority" business.  Then, the owner has to justify how much of a percent minority that he or she is.  That is ridiculous, in my opinion.  Please don't take my comments as not being tolerant or respectful.  I live in a nice mixed subdivision.  I could care less what racial makeup my neighbors might be, as long as they keep up their house well!

Take Care,

John 



From: sasucks
03/19/2008 11:06:14
Very well written...You sound smart...Maybe I'll be able to talk purrty like you one day...


From: de_tox
01/09/2008 11:04:20
well said... (=.


From: ACAC
01/02/2008 08:45:02
I'm working for a state education agency. We do collect a lot of students' data, including their ethnicity. We offer only 5 options for the ethnicity choice. No options like 'Others', 'Mixed', or ‘Don’t know’. And surprisingly almost all (99.9%) students belong to one of the five traditional ethnic groups. I always wonder who decides students' ethnicity.  Most, if not all, of my coworkers hate this categorization, but the agency doesn't change this in the name of data consistency across multiple years.  That's bureaucratic BS, but apparently it is really hard to change. I'm not even sure who insists keeping this policy. Politicians? High-rank bureaucrats? Or anonymous ordinary citizens who don't want to spend tax on this kind of issues?

Thank you for posting an interesting blog. :)


From: GordonGecko
12/15/2007 08:34:44

It is interesting that where I live (UK), Asian usually describes (and is used by) people who are from or have family that were born in India or Pakistan. The BBC Asian network for example has Hindu, Sikh and Islamic music and the presenters are mostly Indian or Pakistani. As I understand it, Indians are not described as Asian in America, is this correct? 



From: iotangel
12/15/2007 02:58:46
i get people commenting on my "race" quite a bit... some people apparently have a hard time accepting someone with light skin/dark hair (which is always mistaken for black). its bizarre. i actually had two 'friends' arguing about my true background in front of me once, and both were wrong and it really irritated me... they didn't want to know the truth. seriously, they had already come up with their own ideas and thought *i* was wrong (for knowing my actual heritage?). wow, that was annoying, but i think a lot of people get this---particularly from stereotypes and what not. its a very shallow nation indeed.

i really hope 'race' DOES die out because it needs to, but... i cant imagine it happening, or at least in my life time... :(


From: Cordell
12/15/2007 02:29:01

hmmm... interesting blog. i have to make one point, though. culture is a necessity, and it is a dying thing. for some reason, people are forgetting where they came from. now, i understand your point that this distinction between people could be divisive, but maybe that point of view should be the thing that goes away. instead of the different cultures.

P.S.- don't shoot me, but i figured you for mediterranean blood... who knows, maybe i'm just blind and just made a fool of myself.




©Social Anxiety Friends ™ 2007, 2008

ICRA